Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

'A contempt of Parliament'

by Aaron Wherry on Friday, June 3, 2011 11:09pm - 166 Comments

A statement this evening from the office of the Speaker of the Senate.

The Honourable Noël A. Kinsella, Speaker of the Senate deplores the actions of a page, which constituted a contempt of Parliament, during the Opening of Parliament in the Senate Chamber today. 

All employees of the Senate are expected to serve the institution in a non-partisan manner, with competence, excellence, efficiency and objectivity.

The Senate has terminated the employee’s contract effective immediately for breaching the terms and conditions of employment. The incident raises serious security concerns which the Senate will fully investigate.

The Speaker of the Senate expresses to His Excellency the Governor General the apology of the Chamber for any embarrassment this incident may have caused.

Evan Solomon interviews Brigette DePape. Jason Kenney deems Ms. DePape a “lefty kook.” CP has reaction from Carolyn Bennett, Justin Trudeau and Senator Pierre Claude Nolin. Comments from Bob Rae and Elizabeth May after the jump.

Mr. Rae.

Well, I mean there is a right to freedom of expression in the country. I don’t think that a ceremony like this should be disrupted.  I think it’s – I think one has to respect the traditions that we have.  She, as a person, she has a right to express her point of view. Obviously as a page she had access to the floor of the Senate and she took advantage of that in order to express her own opinion. So she’ll have to live with the consequences of that.

Ms. May.

Well, [it was] inappropriate. That is the most solemn moment in a parliamentary democracy. We’re essentially in – in theory, we’re in the presence of Her Majesty and the Sovereign. That isn’t Stephen Harper’s room. That’s somebody else’s room. On the other hand, I thought that the act of personal courage was something that you couldn’t avoid. She didn’t shout. She wasn’t disrespectful. Clearly holding a sign up was not appropriate. She was in the wrong room. But her commitment and the concern that all – that many, many Canadian youth come to me all the time that this is their future and when they don’t see climate action, they see their future at stake. So I think that I, while understanding her reasons and feeling that that was a brave act, it was the wrong place.

Bookmark and Share
  • Anonymous

    Love the headline AW. Just look at all the partisans who are taking her to task while remaining in complete denial that the Harper govt was actually found to be in contempt of Parliament. You bad lad you.

    Just watched her video – she’s definitely very young and naive,and yes a bit kooky, but you have to love her passion. Some of the very same people who worry about youth apathy are now all over her. However, she abused her position as a page…full stop…she got fired and that’s fine too. She’s young…that’s her excuse, what’s Kenney’s or Harpers?

  • Anonymous

    Love the headline AW. Just look at all the partisans who are taking her to task while remaining in complete denial that the Harper govt was actually found to be in contempt of Parliament. You bad lad you.

    Just watched her video – she’s definitely very young and naive,and yes a bit kooky, but you have to love her passion. Some of the very same people who worry about youth apathy are now all over her. However, she abused her position as a page…full stop…she got fired and that’s fine too. She’s young…that’s her excuse, what’s Kenney’s or Harpers?

  • Anonymous

    For those of you who have expressed concern about  Brigette DePape’s future….snort….you’ll be happy to know she’s getting job offers, including one with PSAC….and she is also now being featured on Michael Moore’s website.

    http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/Politics/20110605/senate-page-protest-brigette-depape-110605/

    • Anonymous

      Wow, other lefty kooks approve.  What a shock.

      • Anonymous

        Dismissing everyone who ever disagrees with you as ‘lefty kooks’ isn’t going to get you very far in life.

      • Anonymous

        Dismissing everyone who ever disagrees with you as ‘lefty kooks’ isn’t going to get you very far in life.

        • chris burwood

          OE1 ..”Dismissing everyone who ever disagrees with you ” is what you do. Take your own advice sunshine ;)

        • chris burwood

          OE1 ..”Dismissing everyone who ever disagrees with you ” is what you do. Take your own advice sunshine ;)

          • Anonymous

            I dismiss ignorance, not disagreement.

          • Anonymous

            I dismiss ignorance, not disagreement.

        • Anonymous

          Nor will being one, as Ms. DePape will eventually find out.

          • Anonymous

            Well so far,she’s world famous and has a new high-profile job.

            And it’s only Cons who are calling her a ‘lefty kook’….taking their instructions from the Kenney doll.

          • Anonymous

            Well so far,she’s world famous and has a new high-profile job.

            And it’s only Cons who are calling her a ‘lefty kook’….taking their instructions from the Kenney doll.

        • Anonymous

          Nor will being one, as Ms. DePape will eventually find out.

        • Anonymous

          Nor will being one, as Ms. DePape will eventually find out.

      • Anonymous

        Disappointing to see how easily even reasonable people can be goaded into intolerant statements OB. You aren’t setting your side up as the sole arbiter of whose view of society is the “correct” one, are you? Over generalizing is a mug’s game, don’t you think?

      • Anonymous

        Disappointing to see how easily even reasonable people can be goaded into intolerant statements OB. You aren’t setting your side up as the sole arbiter of whose view of society is the “correct” one, are you? Over generalizing is a mug’s game, don’t you think?

      • Anonymous

        Disappointing to see how easily even reasonable people can be goaded into intolerant statements OB. You aren’t setting your side up as the sole arbiter of whose view of society is the “correct” one, are you? Over generalizing is a mug’s game, don’t you think?

      • Anonymous

        Disappointing to see how easily even reasonable people can be goaded into intolerant statements OB. You aren’t setting your side up as the sole arbiter of whose view of society is the “correct” one, are you? Over generalizing is a mug’s game, don’t you think?

    • Anonymous

      Wow, other lefty kooks approve.  What a shock.

  • Anonymous

    For those of you who have expressed concern about  Brigette DePape’s future….snort….you’ll be happy to know she’s getting job offers, including one with PSAC….and she is also now being featured on Michael Moore’s website.

    http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/Politics/20110605/senate-page-protest-brigette-depape-110605/

  • Anonymous

    It’s so funny. The left always accuses the right of forcing their views on others, yet here we have yet another actual example of a leftie trying to force their views on others and, as is often the case, they do it on the taxpayer’s dime. Again, funny.

    • Anonymous

      You mean like Don Cherry taking a swipe at ‘left wing pinkos’ at Rob Ford’s inauguration?

      • Anonymous

        No, don’t quite understand the similarity. Don Cherry is an opinionated commenter — one lonely conservative among many left-wingers at the CBC, by the way — who was invited by the mayor to make an address. This page, on the other hand, took it upon herself to use her taxpayer funded role as an non-partisan servant of the people to shout out her left-wing zealotry.

        • Anonymous

          Both were solemn, supposedly non-partisan ceremonies. Not the right time, not the right place. Perfect analogy? No. Pretty good analogy? Sure is.

        • Anonymous

          Both were solemn, supposedly non-partisan ceremonies. Not the right time, not the right place. Perfect analogy? No. Pretty good analogy? Sure is.

      • Anonymous

        No, don’t quite understand the similarity. Don Cherry is an opinionated commenter — one lonely conservative among many left-wingers at the CBC, by the way — who was invited by the mayor to make an address. This page, on the other hand, took it upon herself to use her taxpayer funded role as an non-partisan servant of the people to shout out her left-wing zealotry.

  • Anonymous

    It’s so funny. The left always accuses the right of forcing their views on others, yet here we have yet another actual example of a leftie trying to force their views on others and, as is often the case, they do it on the taxpayer’s dime. Again, funny.

  • Anonymous

    It’s so funny. The left always accuses the right of forcing their views on others, yet here we have yet another actual example of a leftie trying to force their views on others and, as is often the case, they do it on the taxpayer’s dime. Again, funny.

  • Anonymous

    @google-cbb83dfbc2c6e2ae7af687bdc9229d7c:disqus 
    No sunshine, I work in economics….and you are talking rubbish

    Learn some basics

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money

  • Anonymous

    @google-cbb83dfbc2c6e2ae7af687bdc9229d7c:disqus 
    No sunshine, I work in economics….and you are talking rubbish

    Learn some basics

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money

  • Anonymous

    @google-cbb83dfbc2c6e2ae7af687bdc9229d7c:disqus 
    No sunshine, I work in economics….and you are talking rubbish

    Learn some basics

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1492454455 Mary Choma

    I say thanks to this young woman for having the guts to stand up to the power of these twisted institutions of parliament.  Harper was found to be in contempt, he broke election laws by promoting his party on the radio on election day – complaint file, no response – he lied about a coalition government, he refused to reveal costs for jets, jails, cuts soon to be unleashed, he has fired civil servants who dared question him, he kicked voters out of his meetings because of his paranoia that maybe they’d been at another candidate’s event, Conservative candidates did not show up to debate or discuss issues at open forums during the campaign….it’s a long list.  Respect for parliament?  How can it be in a democracy that an extremist can become the PM with only 24% of support from eligible voters in this country?  Wake up people!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1492454455 Mary Choma

    I say thanks to this young woman for having the guts to stand up to the power of these twisted institutions of parliament.  Harper was found to be in contempt, he broke election laws by promoting his party on the radio on election day – complaint file, no response – he lied about a coalition government, he refused to reveal costs for jets, jails, cuts soon to be unleashed, he has fired civil servants who dared question him, he kicked voters out of his meetings because of his paranoia that maybe they’d been at another candidate’s event, Conservative candidates did not show up to debate or discuss issues at open forums during the campaign….it’s a long list.  Respect for parliament?  How can it be in a democracy that an extremist can become the PM with only 24% of support from eligible voters in this country?  Wake up people!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1492454455 Mary Choma

    I say thanks to this young woman for having the guts to stand up to the power of these twisted institutions of parliament.  Harper was found to be in contempt, he broke election laws by promoting his party on the radio on election day – complaint file, no response – he lied about a coalition government, he refused to reveal costs for jets, jails, cuts soon to be unleashed, he has fired civil servants who dared question him, he kicked voters out of his meetings because of his paranoia that maybe they’d been at another candidate’s event, Conservative candidates did not show up to debate or discuss issues at open forums during the campaign….it’s a long list.  Respect for parliament?  How can it be in a democracy that an extremist can become the PM with only 24% of support from eligible voters in this country?  Wake up people!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1492454455 Mary Choma

    I say thanks to this young woman for having the guts to stand up to the power of these twisted institutions of parliament.  Harper was found to be in contempt, he broke election laws by promoting his party on the radio on election day – complaint file, no response – he lied about a coalition government, he refused to reveal costs for jets, jails, cuts soon to be unleashed, he has fired civil servants who dared question him, he kicked voters out of his meetings because of his paranoia that maybe they’d been at another candidate’s event, Conservative candidates did not show up to debate or discuss issues at open forums during the campaign….it’s a long list.  Respect for parliament?  How can it be in a democracy that an extremist can become the PM with only 24% of support from eligible voters in this country?  Wake up people!!

  • Anonymous

    On the subject of the Page being in Contempt of Parliament and getting fired for her actions.  Seems to me that “The man who would be King…..Harper” was found in contempt of Parliament but he was not penalised in any way. In  fact he is CONTROLLING the Country, methinks there is a double standard here!!!  I dread to think what kind of financial mess the Country will be in after his 4 years in Office…….we will be destitute!!

From Macleans