Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

The Commons: Tony Clement's bike racks, streetlights and boulevards

by Aaron Wherry on Thursday, June 9, 2011 6:41pm - 126 Comments

The Scene. By Thomas Mulcair’s reckoning this was a scandal—”Sponsorship scandal 2.0,” he dubbed it, perhaps hopefully.

The Prime Minister moved quickly to correct the NDP deputy. The Auditor General, Mr. Harper explained, had merely “suggested several recommendations to improve the process in the future.”

Mr. Mulcair was unpersuaded. “No accountability, no transparency, no justification of decisions,” he cried, reviewing the charges.

The Prime Minister stuck to his story. “As I said before,” he recounted, “the Auditor General suggested several recommendations to improve the approval process in the future and we will accept its recommendations.”

Mr. Mulcair fumed for a third time—Parliament kept in the dark, funds redirected, a restored steamboat, etc—but Mr. Harper only barely budged. “The Auditor General has suggested changes in the estimates process to improve transparency,” the Prime Minister allowed.

For sure, that is one way of putting it. Less charitably, one might say that Tony Clement stands accused of not only using public funds to spread trinkets around his riding, but of drawing those funds from an account approved by Parliament for the purposes of “border infrastructure” and of constructing a selection process that involved only Mr. Clement and several small town mayors and that left no paper trail.

The sort of thing, in other words, that would’ve driven a younger Stephen Harper and various members of the governing caucus—fun fact: the Conservative side includes not one, but now two former directors of the presumptuously named Canadian Taxpayers Federation—to fits of righteous indignation and principled outrage.

If the government would not express shame now, the NDP’s Charlie Angus moved to impose it upon them. “Mr. Speaker, the Auditor General revealed today that the Treasury Board allowed the former minister of industry to set up a $47 million slush fund for pork-barrel projects in his riding,” he recounted. “Here is how it went down: There was the minister, there was a mayor and there was a hotel manager who dished out the loot. There was no oversight. There was no documentation. There were no questions asked. This is just one step up from cash in a brown paper bag.”

There were groans and hisses from the Conservative benches.

“So,” Mr. Angus finally asked, “is this how the minister will plan to run the Treasury Board?”

Momentarily struck with the inability to stand and account for himself, Tony Clement was compelled to remain seated and let John Baird take this one. Mr. Baird was, understandably, besmirched. ”Mr. Speaker,” he sighed, “so much for the civility that the leader of the opposition promised Canadians.”

“Mr. Speaker,” Mr. Angus shot back, “there is nothing civil about the abuse of taxpayers’ trust.”

So perplexing was the abuse that the New Democrat was now moved to explain it in old timey terms. “They told us that they were requesting money for border infrastructure and they fuddled it off for pork-barrel projects on gazebos and steamboats and everything else the minister could think of,” Mr. Angus proclaimed. “This is the kind of rum-bottle, pork-barrel politics that Canadians are fed up with.”

Mr. Baird was once more disappointed. “Mr. Speaker, my colleague opposite from Timmins—James Bay is making it up as he goes along,” he lamented. “In fact, not one of the 32 projects was a steamship.”

Indeed, we must be precise. We all surely owe Mr. Baird and Mr. Clement that much. So let it be noted here and noted by all that the antique steamboat was, in fact, funded through an entirely different envelope of public money and there is a difference between the funds that were used to restore the SS Bigwin and the funds—the G8 Legacy funds—that were used to build new public washrooms in Burk’s Falls (44km from the summit site), a new gazebo in Seguin (67km from the summit), new streetlights in Kearney (40km from the site), new paving stone boulevards in Parry Sound (100km from the summit) and the new town clock in Sundridge (63km from the site).

Mock the bike racks in South River (72km from the summit) if you must, but let us agree here and now that the Bigwin, that fine sailing ship, should not have its good name tarnished by association.

In the interests of drawing fine distinctions, Bob Rae next turned to one of the larger points here. “Mr. Speaker, to the Prime Minister, he cannot get around the fact that in November 2009, the supplementary estimates tabled in Parliament included a request for approval to spend $83 million for an item entitled: ‘border Infrastructure fund related to investments in infrastructure to reduce border congestion,’ ” the Liberal leader ventured. “The simple fact is, the government used that money for a completely different purpose. Huntsville is 300 miles away from the closest border in Niagara Falls. How does he explain this bait and switch?”

Turns out, the Prime Minister explains it quite easily. “Mr. Speaker, if the leader of the Liberal Party had looked at the border fund he would realize that it is frequently used for projects that are not in border communities,” Mr. Harper said.

In his days of minority government, Mr. Harper might’ve been expected to merely shrug away an accusation of wrongdoing (see his aforementioned exchange with Mr. Mulcair). But is the Prime Minister so relaxed now in the wake of majority victory that he is willing to confess to levels of looseness to which he was not even accused? There were guffaws from the Liberal corner at whatever this was meant to be.

A short while later, Judy Foote stood to ask how the government could justify spending on “fake lakes and gazeboes,” while cutting funds for search and rescue operations in Newfoundland. In response, Fisheries Minister Keith Ashfield would assure the House that no one’s safety will be compromised, but not before first reminding everyone of what happened last month.

“Mr. Speaker,” he said, “we are acting on the strong mandate that we received from Canadians to implement our budget proposals and deficit reduction measures.” He might’ve stuck a period after “Canadians.” And the government side might as well make that the answer to every question for at least the next few years.

Coincidentally, Mr. Harper spent much of the rest of the hour sharing smiles and laughs with members of his frontbench. He seemed to be in a positively delightful mood.

The Stats. The G8 summit, nine questions. Aboriginal affairs, five questions. Libya, four questions. HIV, Canada Post, telecommunications, credit cards, shipbuilding and the environment, two questions each. The RCMP, veterans, fisheries, bilingualism, taxation, equality, seniors and the budget, one question each.

John Baird, seven answers. Stephen Harper, five answers. John Duncan, four answers. Jim Flaherty and Rona Ambrose, three answers each. Chris Alexander, Leona Aglukkaq, Christian Paradis and Peter Kent, two answers each. Rick Dykstra, Vic Toews, Lois Brown, Keith Ashfield, James Moore, Tony Clement, Lisa Raitt and Steven Fletcher, one answer each.

Bookmark and Share
  • Phil King

    And the transformation is complete.

    Harper is now officially Chretien 2.0.

  • Phil King

    And the transformation is complete.

    Harper is now officially Chretien 2.0.

  • Phil King

    And the transformation is complete.

    Harper is now officially Chretien 2.0.

  • Anonymous

    It is little wonder that so many Canadians get turned off by our parliamentary representatives.  It is OUR money that is being shoveled to so many pig sties.  Maybe it is my fault to have expected proper behaviour from fiscal conservatives

  • Anonymous

    It is little wonder that so many Canadians get turned off by our parliamentary representatives.  It is OUR money that is being shoveled to so many pig sties.  Maybe it is my fault to have expected proper behaviour from fiscal conservatives

  • Anonymous

    Although I voted Conservative, this is outrageous.

    • Anonymous

      Please. As if you didn’t expect this would happen.

      The only way that could be true is either you’re wilfully blind, or simply haven’t been paying attention for the last four years.

      • Anonymous

        Well, yes. Disgusting Ontario pork barrel, but at least not the grossly criminal Liberal sponsorship scandal. Obviously a flaw  in the juncture between pristine, honest Western Reform and Eastern dry rot. As well, let me tell you about some of the NDP scandals some day.  Unfortunately, to err is human.

  • Anonymous

    Although I voted Conservative, this is outrageous.

  • Anonymous

    being in opposition , continually, of everything, certainly will wear the NDP down, just look at Sheeley Martel’s face. ,, opposing bike racks.. whats next.. ?? JanBC… Id like some enterprising journalist to look into the “massage Parlour” story. so many unanswred yet easily asked questions .. such as was anyone charged that night? etc. This stinks of a cover up.

  • Anonymous

    being in opposition , continually, of everything, certainly will wear the NDP down, just look at Sheeley Martel’s face. ,, opposing bike racks.. whats next.. ?? JanBC… Id like some enterprising journalist to look into the “massage Parlour” story. so many unanswred yet easily asked questions .. such as was anyone charged that night? etc. This stinks of a cover up.

  • Anonymous

    The Baird/Clements response to getting caught reminds me of the joke about the ” old salt”, who, on his deathbed is worried that he hasn’t been as good as he might have been through his life.  The attending Minister, offering solace, suggests that he concentrate on the positive:  ”think of the 10 commandments and list all of them that you haven’t broken”.  The dying sailor contemplates this suggestion, brightens up and says : “well.. I’ve never made a graven image…”

    I expect that the creator of this joke is a strategist for the Conservative party..

  • Anonymous

    The Baird/Clements response to getting caught reminds me of the joke about the ” old salt”, who, on his deathbed is worried that he hasn’t been as good as he might have been through his life.  The attending Minister, offering solace, suggests that he concentrate on the positive:  ”think of the 10 commandments and list all of them that you haven’t broken”.  The dying sailor contemplates this suggestion, brightens up and says : “well.. I’ve never made a graven image…”

    I expect that the creator of this joke is a strategist for the Conservative party..

  • Anonymous

    Let’s hope Macleans and the media in general stay on this until someone takes responsibility .. 

    • Anonymous

      You mean the way they’ve looked at everything.  Ha Ha Ha!  The only thing the media looks into is the Conservative Party.  How about Elections Canada?  The leadership “race” of 2006.  Have these Lieberals yet paid off their debt?  No, they have not.  They keep getting extensions.  As to the money spent in T. Clements riding, why hasn’t anyone raked the bureaucrats over the coals who were supposed to be doing their job?  Don’t look to the media, they have their own agenda.

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Thanks flagging egregious details tho’ has led to surfeit of gagging over this galling getaway with highway robbery by Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Bear Baird’s bluster & buffoonery … Who does Baird think he, Clement, Harper & Co. kidding – only themselves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled,  mighty displeased Harper CONservatives think can get away with atest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation really = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s own constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” to public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Thanks flagging egregious details tho’ has led to surfeit of gagging over this galling getaway with highway robbery by Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Bear Baird’s bluster & buffoonery … Who does Baird think he, Clement, Harper & Co. kidding – only themselves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled,  mighty displeased Harper CONservatives think can get away with atest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation really = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s own constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” to public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Thanks flagging egregious details tho’ has led to surfeit of gagging over this galling getaway with highway robbery by Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Bear Baird’s bluster & buffoonery … Who does Baird think he, Clement, Harper & Co. kidding – only themselves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled,  mighty displeased Harper CONservatives think can get away with atest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation really = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s own constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” to public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Thanks flagging egregious details tho’ has led to surfeit of gagging over this galling getaway with highway robbery by Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Bear Baird’s bluster & buffoonery … Who does Baird think he, Clement, Harper & Co. kidding – only themselves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled,  mighty displeased Harper CONservatives think can get away with atest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation really = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s own constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” to public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Thanks flagging egregious details tho’ has led to surfeit of gagging over this galling getaway with highway robbery by Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Bear Baird’s bluster & buffoonery … Who does Baird think he, Clement, Harper & Co. kidding – only themselves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled,  mighty displeased Harper CONservatives think can get away with atest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation really = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s own constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” to public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Flagging egregious details has led to surfeit of gagging this galling getaway with highway robbery Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Baird’s blustery buffoonery. Who think they’re kidding — only selves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled, mighty displeased Harper’s gang think can get away with latest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Flagging egregious details has led to surfeit of gagging this galling getaway with highway robbery Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Baird’s blustery buffoonery. Who think they’re kidding — only selves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled, mighty displeased Harper’s gang think can get away with latest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Flagging egregious details has led to surfeit of gagging this galling getaway with highway robbery Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Baird’s blustery buffoonery. Who think they’re kidding — only selves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled, mighty displeased Harper’s gang think can get away with latest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Flagging egregious details has led to surfeit of gagging this galling getaway with highway robbery Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Baird’s blustery buffoonery. Who think they’re kidding — only selves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled, mighty displeased Harper’s gang think can get away with latest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

  • http://twitter.com/AstuteCitizen M.C. Kelly

    Flagging egregious details has led to surfeit of gagging this galling getaway with highway robbery Harper CONservative carpet-bagging bandits! No surprise usually gabby Clement hiding behind Big Bad Baird’s blustery buffoonery. Who think they’re kidding — only selves maybe. Savvy Canadian voter-citizen-TAXPAYERS sure aren’t fooled, mighty displeased Harper’s gang think can get away with latest “contempt of Parliament, breach of trust” revelation = contempt for ALL Canadian TAXPAYERS. Including Clement’s constituents — walked out in disgust & “called him out” public meetings mid-Federal Election 2011 campaign when leaked draft A-G’s report first brought flagrant “Tony & John foolery” public’s, media’s & Opposition Parties’ attention!
    – Mary C. Kelly, Toronto Centre Constituent

From Macleans