Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

What you don’t know

by Aaron Wherry on Friday, December 9, 2011 10:03am - 8 Comments

A former Progressive Conservative MP and Justice Department advisor says the government’s crime legislation will lead to worsening conditions in prisons.

Mr. Daubney said that, since the mid-2000s, the Justice Department has asked for less and less research to be undertaken and typically ignores recommendations against policies such as mandatory minimum sentences or prison expansion. “It is kind of sad that I have to do this, but somebody has to take the risk of talking,” Mr. Daubney said. “I feel sad for my colleagues who are still there. It was clear the government wasn’t interested in what the research said or in evidence that was quite convincingly set out.”

The prison ombudsman adds his concerns. A study by the Quebec Institute for Socio-economic Research and Information projects a total cost of $19 billion to build and expand prisons.

Bookmark and Share
  • gtrplyr055

    We’ll all soon be in debtor’s prison with this spendthrift PM.

  • Hester Eastman

    I would like to see some evidence that criminologists know wtf they are talking about. Have yet to see any proof that criminologists and their vacuous policies don’t lead to more crime. 

    And someone should remind/inform? Mr Daubney that elections have consequences. 

    Theodore Dalrymple ~ Salisbury Review:

    “Perhaps the most important is that intellectuals live in a costless world in which there is every incentive to devise other theories that defy common sense …. 

    Intellectuals, like everyone else, live and work in a marketplace. In order to get noticed they must say things which have not been said before, or at least say them in a different manner. 

    No one is likely to obtain many plaudits for the rather obvious, indeed self-evident, thought that a street robber cannot commit street robberies while he is in prison; but an intellectual who first demonstrates that the cause of an increase in street robbery is the increase in the amount of property that law-abiding pedestrians have on them as they walk in the streets is likely to be hailed, at least until the next idea comes along. 

    Thus, while there are no penalties for being foolish, there are severe penalties (at least in career terms) for being obvious.

    • Anonymous

      I would like to see some evidence that those who aren’t criminologists know wtf they are talking about.  Have yet to see any proof that non-criminologists and their vacuous policies don’t lead to more crime.

      P.S. rich as always with your comments that you simultaneously bash intellectuals and then quote an intellectual to support your opinions.

  • Babe65

    We sure don’t need more petty criminals…why don’t we train them to be honest investment bankers or politicians?

  • Anonymous

    Don’t worry about it. The bill’s never going to make it through the Conservative senate anyway. They couldn’t campaign on it if it ever got passed.

  • Anonymous

    I actually made a bet with a friend yesterday that C10 won’t receive royal assent before the end of this session.

    • Anonymous

      I think you might win that bet.

      I’m not sure it’ll receive royal assent before the end of this DECADE.

      Thank God.

  • Anonymous

    “A former Progressive Conservative MP and Justice Department advisor says the government’s crime legislation will lead to worsening conditions in prisons.”

    Good

From Macleans